UPDATE: Oak Creek officials have just announced a major overhaul of the town’s nuisance code to enhance enforcement and tackle problem properties effectively. In a pivotal meeting on January 22, 2024, Town Administrator Louis Fineberg proposed a shift from the current enforcement system to a court-based approach, aiming to streamline processes and reduce political pressures.
This urgent initiative comes as residents have voiced growing concerns over neglected properties and safety issues. Fineberg emphasized that the existing code is “not workable,” and after receiving numerous complaints about junk accumulation and derelict buildings, officials are eager to act. Mayor Melissa Dobbins described the proposed changes as “the meat and potatoes of what the community is asking for,” highlighting a strong desire for resolution.
Currently, the town’s nuisance violations are managed through a “quasi-judicial” system overseen by the Board of Trustees, which Fineberg says is ineffective. The new proposal would allow code enforcement officers to issue written requests for property corrections, giving owners a strict timeframe—such as seven days—to address violations. Should they fail to comply, cases will advance to municipal court, where judges can impose fines or mandate further actions.
The transition aims to create a clearer, more legally defensible system, minimizing the risk of political bias in enforcement. Fineberg noted, “Everybody has to be on board here with the notion of enforcement…otherwise, if there’s political pressure on who gets enforced, these things tend to fall apart.”
As part of the overhaul, officials plan to refine definitions for terms like “noxious weeds” and “stagnant ponds” to eliminate ambiguity and ensure consistent application of the code. Fineberg stated, “When it comes to enforcement, it needs to be black and white. It can’t be open to interpretation.”
However, Dobbins acknowledged the sensitive nature of these changes, especially for longtime residents who may struggle to adapt to stricter rules. She cautioned that the enforcement could provoke resistance among some community members, stressing the need for a respectful approach to implementation.
Fineberg, who started in his role in June, revealed that addressing code enforcement was a priority discussed during his job interview. “The town had let me know that they wanted to pursue code enforcement because they felt it was too lax here,” he said.
No formal vote occurred at the meeting, but Fineberg plans to present a revised draft at the Board’s upcoming meeting on February 26, 2024. He aims to have the new code in effect by spring, pending approval from Town Attorney Robert Weiss and Municipal Judge Jessica Ryan.
Residents can expect a more consistent and fair approach to code enforcement, which officials hope will lead to a safer community and improved property values. The urgency of the situation is clear, as Oak Creek strives to reclaim its character and enhance the quality of life for all its residents.
