Shoppers in Philadelphia will face a new challenge at checkout counters starting January 2024 as a city law mandating a **10-cent fee** on paper bags takes effect. This initiative aims to tackle environmental waste, following the city’s earlier ban on plastic bags. City Councilman **Mark Squilla** introduced the legislation, which was approved by the city council with a **10-5** vote on **October 30, 2023**. The law was enacted without the signature of Mayor **Cherelle Parker**, who expressed support for the intentions behind the measure but raised concerns about its implications for vulnerable residents.
The paper bag fee intends to encourage shoppers to bring their own reusable bags, a practice that has gained traction since the ban on plastic bags was implemented in 2021. **Squilla** noted that the increased use of paper bags since the plastic ban has raised environmental concerns, particularly related to the energy needed for their production. “We saw in the past, once there’s a fee associated with it, even if it’s 10 cents, it’s enough to make people remember to bring their own bag,” he stated to **The Philly Voice**.
While the fee applies only to retail establishments, it excludes deliveries, drive-thrus, and takeout orders. The revenue generated from the fee will go directly to the stores, rather than the city, prompting some residents to question the effectiveness of the legislation. On the **Philadelphia subreddit**, one user expressed disbelief that the city would not benefit financially, stating, “I think it’s insane the city is not even getting any money from this; the stores get to keep the 10 cents.”
Concerns about the fee’s impact on lower-income residents have been echoed by **Parker**. In a statement, she highlighted potential unintended consequences, particularly for individuals relying on **SNAP** or **WIC** benefits. “I remain concerned with some of the unintended consequences this legislation could have for our local economy and low-income Philadelphians, especially our communities of color,” she remarked.
Residents have voiced their opinions on the new fee, with some acknowledging the need for environmental action while also expressing frustration at the additional financial burden. **Billy Milhouse**, a local shopper, pointed out, “If you need more than one bag, like five bags, that’s 50 cents.” Similarly, **Joyce Isley** noted the cumulative effect of the fee, particularly for those on fixed incomes or students.
As the implementation date approaches, city officials may consider extending the timeline for full enforcement. The introduction of this fee represents a significant shift in the city’s approach to waste management and environmental responsibility. While the legislation aims to promote sustainability, it also underscores the balancing act between environmental initiatives and the financial realities faced by residents.
As Philadelphia navigates this new chapter in its environmental policies, the effectiveness and reception of the paper bag fee will likely continue to generate discussion among residents, businesses, and policymakers alike.
