Taylor Frankie Paul has stirred up speculation about a potential reconciliation with Chase McWhorter following her complicated romance with Dakota Mortensen. The reality star, known for her role in the hit series Secret Lives of Mormon Wives, hinted at the rekindling of old feelings during the season three finale, which premiered on November 13, 2024.
During a significant lunch meeting, Chase apologized for past behaviors, marking a shift in their relationship dynamic. The two reflected on their history and even joked about sharing a kiss, a stark contrast to their previous interactions that were fraught with tension. This development comes in the wake of Taylor’s controversial involvement in a “soft swinging” scandal that captured public attention before the show aired in September 2024.
The controversy began when Taylor, still married to Tate Paul, was reported to have engaged in sexual encounters with various couples, including Chase and his then-wife, Miranda McWhorter. Taylor explained in season two of the show that her connection with Chase had led to misunderstandings, saying, “Her husband was the one who had feelings for me. That’s where the story gets confusing.” She emphasized that if Miranda were truly her best friend, she would never have pursued such actions.
The fallout from the scandal contributed to Taylor and Tate’s separation. The couple, who share two children—Indy, aged 7, and Ocean, aged 4—ultimately ended their marriage. Following her divorce, Taylor began dating Dakota Mortensen, with whom she welcomed their son, Ever, in 2024. However, their relationship also ended amid rumors of infidelity involving Dakota.
Chase’s own marriage to Miranda ended in 2024, following their earlier involvement in the scandal. Reflecting on the past, Chase stated, “I think we all have regrets. We probably should have not been there.” He expressed frustration regarding the public nature of their situation, suggesting that it had become a platform for Taylor’s rise to fame.
Chase McWhorter’s Background and Comments on the Scandal
Chase and Miranda began dating in 2016 after connecting on social media and married a year later. They welcomed two children, Brooks in 2019 and Cohen in 2021, before parting ways. In a previous interview, Chase described their relationship post-divorce as “cordial” and “friendly,” noting that they maintain a positive co-parenting dynamic.
Chase elaborated on the events surrounding the scandal, stating that it originated during the COVID-19 pandemic when he and his friends experimented with casual games involving alcohol. He clarified, “It was never predetermined that we were going to be doing, like, swinging.” This statement contrasts with how Taylor has portrayed their experiences.
During the season three finale, Chase surprised Taylor by revealing he had recently ended a relationship with another partner. He characterized their lunch as a date, leading to discussions about their past feelings for each other. “Honestly, Taylor, I always thought you were one of the coolest people ever,” Chase told her. Taylor acknowledged her flirtatious nature, indicating that their chemistry was undeniable.
The episode concluded with Chase suggesting they share a kiss for “old times’ sake,” leaving viewers questioning the future of their relationship. Following the filming, Taylor was cast as the lead for the upcoming season of The Bachelorette, indicating that she may not pursue a romantic connection with Chase at this time.
Chase’s name surfaced again in season three due to his podcast, “OnlyDads,” which drew criticism from cast members for comments deemed inappropriate. Mayci Neeley, one of the cast members, referred to him as a “scumbag” for his remarks, emphasizing the ongoing tension within the show’s community.
As the drama continues to unfold, fans are left to speculate about the implications of Taylor’s recent interactions with Chase and how they might affect her burgeoning career in reality television.
