UPDATE: A high school sophomore in New Baltimore, Michigan, is facing backlash and threats after starting a conservative club at Anchor Bay High School. Madalynn Watraz launched Club America, affiliated with Turning Point USA, to provide a space for conservative students but encountered unexpected hostility following an Instagram post promoting the club.
Just days after the club’s meeting on February 12, 2025, where members made Valentine’s Day cards for seniors, Watraz found her promotional posters removed from school grounds. An anonymous Facebook post featuring one of her posters sparked a flood of comments, with over 165 reactions ranging from support to severe criticism, including threats against her safety.
Watraz expressed her concerns in an email to school officials, citing potential violations of her First Amendment rights. “I am concerned because the removal of these posters may represent an infringement on my free expression,” she wrote, requesting an investigation into the incident. The school district has acknowledged the issue and is currently reviewing security footage.
The situation escalated dramatically when Watraz received threatening phone calls from anonymous numbers, warning her to “watch her back.” She recounted, “They told me that I needed to watch my back and be careful.” This intimidation has left her feeling anxious about attending school and participating in extracurricular activities.
As the controversy continues to unfold, Watraz has noted that some students are fearful of expressing conservative views due to similar threats. “I know of students at my school who don’t want to be open about their conservative views because they’re afraid,” she said.
Watraz’s mother, Megan Hemp-Watraz, expressed her distress over the situation, emphasizing the alarming response from both students and adults. “It’s alarming the amount of adults that have gone after her. It is crazy to me,” she stated, highlighting the emotional toll on her daughter.
While Dominic Vendittelli, the school board member who encouraged the establishment of Club America, has not yet commented, the district is under pressure to address the rising tensions. Chelsey Schell, a district spokesperson, confirmed that the situation is being investigated but stated there was no mention of threats in the initial communications from Watraz.
The incident raises critical questions about free speech and political expression in schools, particularly as students navigate an increasingly polarized environment. With the emotional and social well-being of students at stake, the community is watching closely to see how school officials will respond to this urgent matter.
As of now, Watraz remains determined to continue her efforts with Club America, despite the hostile climate. She maintains that the challenges she faces are part of her journey in advocating for conservative values, urging other students to stand firm in their beliefs.
This developing story underscores the complexities of political expression in educational settings and the urgent need for dialogue and understanding among students of all beliefs. Stay tuned for further updates on this unfolding situation.
