UPDATE: A historic church in Virginia Beach is making headlines as it requests to exit its historic zoning designation, raising urgent questions about the future of the area’s preservation efforts. On December 6, 2023, the Planning Commission heard an unusual plea from Nimmo United Methodist Church, the oldest Methodist church in continuous use in the United States, seeking removal from the Nimmo Church Historical and Cultural District.
This request, if granted, could dismantle the historic district altogether, prompting concerns among city officials about the implications for other designated areas. The church argues that the costs associated with necessary repairs and improvements are financially prohibitive under the current zoning regulations.
Mark Reed, the city’s historic preservation planner, highlighted that the church’s removal request stems from “significant material and labor costs” required for upkeep. The Historical Review Board and the Historic Preservation Commission have both denied the church’s requests, stating that such a precedent could jeopardize the integrity of Virginia Beach’s historic areas.
Commissioners expressed their need for further information, deferring a decision until January 14, 2024. “It’s an important issue affecting our consideration of this district and other districts throughout the city,” stated Commissioner Bryan Plumlee.
The Nimmo district, established in 1980, plays a crucial role in preserving the city’s historical identity, which spans from the Colonial era to the 20th century. Virginia Beach is home to 16 Historical and Cultural Districts, each requiring rigorous review for any proposed alterations, ensuring that developments align with historical standards.
Recent applications in these districts have included both minor and significant alterations, but the board has consistently enforced strict design guidelines, often ignoring cost implications. The board’s refusal to allow changes to the church’s property, such as a proposed welcome center in front of its historic steeple, has drawn criticism for being overly stringent.
Councilwoman Barbara Henley, who represents District 2 where the church is located, shares concerns about the current standards. She expressed hope for a compromise that balances historic preservation with the church’s need for affordable enhancements. “Being in the (historic and cultural) district, they’re just required to meet the highest standard of historic preservation,” Henley noted, emphasizing the financial strain it can impose on property owners.
The church has not recently submitted any applications for maintenance or repair, leaving unanswered questions about the specific improvements it seeks. The last major approval from the board was in 2021, when three additions were sanctioned, but subsequent requests have been met with resistance.
As the situation unfolds, the impact on Virginia Beach’s preservation efforts is clear. The outcome of the Planning Commission’s decision in January could reshape the future of historic districts citywide, making this a pivotal moment for both the church and the community.
Stay tuned for updates as this developing story continues to unfold.
